What are the Most Popular Pizza Toppings?

When it comes to pizza toppings, we know our Oak Park customers like what they like, and there’s nothing wrong with ordering your favorite pizza toppings when it’s pizza for just you or your family. But if you’re ordering pizza for a crowd and trying to please everyone? Knowing the most popular pizza toppings can come in handy. After all, you don’t want to start a controversy at your next party by ordering pineapple on your pizza. Take a look at the most popular pizza toppings, then start planning which ones will make the cut next time you order from Salerno’s Pizza near Berwyn or Forest Park. 

pepperoni pizza

Favorite Pizza Toppings—and Least Favorites

According to Huffington Post, there aren’t any surprises in the top five favorite pizza toppings: pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, and bacon. There probably weren’t many surprises among the least-favorite pizza toppings, either: anchovies, eggplant, pineapple, and artichokes. 


Meanwhile, USA Today’s poll went a bit deeper and has some arguments to make with HuffPo. While they also had pepperoni as their most popular pizza topping, the rest of their countdown included, in order: mushrooms, onion, sausage, bacon, extra cheese, black olives, green peppers, pineapple, and spinach. 

But what about closer to home in Stickney? How to Cook offers a state-by-state look at popular pizza toppings. In Illinois sausage reigns supreme, as it does in neighboring Indiana and Wisconsin. When you consider places like Salerno’s Pizza who make their sausage from scratch, it’s no wonder it’s a favorite pizza topping! We use our old school recipe Italian sausage on plenty of pizzas that go out the door to Brookfield and Riverside. It’s definitely our favorite pizza topping!

Find Your Favorite Pizza Toppings at Salerno’s

What’s your favorite pizza topping? Let us know next time you order Salerno’s Pizza! Our extensive list of pizza toppings has something for everyone. And yes, that includes pineapple. If you’re trying to please a crowd try our Supreme Pizza, which is loaded with favorite pizza toppings that include our scratch-made sausage, fresh-cut mushrooms, onions, and green peppers. No matter what your favorite pizza topping might be, it’s always better when it’s fresh and made by hand at Salerno’s. Check our menu for all your favorites! 

Oak Park

© Copyright 2023 @ Salernospizza . All Rights Reserved